2024 Jayco Melbourne 24T vs 2024 Thor Compass 23TW

Detailed Comparison

Before committing to the 2024 Jayco Melbourne 24T or the 2024 Thor Compass 23TW, it pays to understand exactly where each one shines and where it falls short.

Starting with size, the Jayco Melbourne 24T measures 24.5 ft long and tips the scales at 10,000 lbs dry weight. The Thor Compass 23TW comes in at 25.5 ft with a dry weight of 17,700 lbs.

The Jayco Melbourne 24T sleeps 6 while the Thor Compass 23TW accommodates 5. Slide-outs play a role in livability: the Jayco Melbourne 24T has 3 and the Thor Compass 23TW has 0.

For boondocking enthusiasts, tank sizes matter. Fresh water capacity goes to the Thor Compass 23TW at 49 gallons versus 49 gallons. Solar-wise, you get 150W on the Jayco Melbourne 24T and 350W on the Thor Compass 23TW. Battery banks are 150 Ah and 150 Ah.

At $82,000 MSRP for the Jayco Melbourne 24T and $77,000 for the Thor Compass 23TW, the Thor Compass 23TW saves you $5,000. With only a 6% price difference, the choice comes down to features rather than cost.

If you're traveling with a family, look for the model with more sleeping positions and better storage. Boondockers: look at the fresh water capacity and solar/battery systems — they determine how long you can stay out. If you're a weekend camper, don't over-buy — the smaller, lighter model may serve you perfectly.

The numbers tell one story, but the feel of a floor plan is personal. Schedule a walkthrough before you decide.