2024 Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL vs 2024 Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF

Detailed Comparison

If you're weighing the 2024 Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL against the 2024 Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF, you're looking at two solid contenders. Here's how they stack up.

Starting with size, the Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL measures 37.5 ft long and tips the scales at 11,700 lbs dry weight. The Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF comes in at 39.0 ft with a dry weight of 13,900 lbs.

The Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL sleeps 8 while the Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF accommodates 10. Slide-outs play a role in livability: the Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL has 3 and the Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF has 2.

For boondocking enthusiasts, tank sizes matter. Fresh water capacity goes to the Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL at 93 gallons versus 70 gallons. Solar-wise, you get 350W on the Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL and 250W on the Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF. Battery banks are 150 Ah and 250 Ah.

At $136,000 MSRP for the Grand Design Solitude S-Class 3460FL and $135,000 for the Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF, the Dutchmen Astoria 3163RLF saves you $1,000. With only a 1% price difference, the choice comes down to features rather than cost.

If you're traveling with a family, look for the model with more sleeping positions and better storage. Boondockers: look at the fresh water capacity and solar/battery systems — they determine how long you can stay out. For the full-time RV lifestyle, every gallon of tank capacity and every inch of counter space counts.

Ultimately, both rigs have their merits — test drive each one and see which floor plan speaks to your lifestyle.