2025 Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS vs 2024 Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B

Detailed Comparison

Comparing the 2025 Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS to the 2024 Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B reveals some interesting trade-offs that could influence your buying decision.

In terms of footprint, the Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS stretches 34.0 ft while the Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B spans 34.0 ft. Weight-wise, the Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B is the lighter rig at 3,800 lbs versus 7,900 lbs.

Capacity-wise, expect to sleep 8 in the Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS versus 10 in the Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B. With 0 and 1 slide-outs respectively, the parked floor plans differ significantly.

Tank capacities are a key off-grid consideration. The Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS carries 58 gal of fresh water, 52 gal gray, and 32 gal black. The Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B offers 46 gal fresh, 37 gal gray, and 28 gal black. The Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS has the edge for extended dry camping.

Budget-wise, the Dutchmen Coleman Lantern 17B is listed at $61,000 compared to $61,000 for the Coachmen Catalina Summit 184BHS.

For family camping trips, the larger floor plan and additional berths make a real difference. For boondocking, the model with superior solar and battery setup will keep you comfortable off the grid longer. If you're going full-time, the larger tanks and more robust build quality matter enormously.

At the end of the day, the best RV is the one that fits your travel dreams and budget. Either of these is a worthy choice.