2024 Thor Tuscany 45MX vs 2025 American Coach American Revolution 42S

Detailed Comparison

Choosing between the 2024 Thor Tuscany 45MX and the 2025 American Coach American Revolution 42S? Both are excellent options in the RV world, but they cater to different priorities.

The Thor Tuscany 45MX measures 34.5 ft in length at 23,500 lbs, compared to the American Coach American Revolution 42S's 36.5 ft and 27,800 lbs. GVWR ratings sit at 28,100 lbs and 30,200 lbs respectively.

For sleeping arrangements, the Thor Tuscany 45MX offers room for 5 and the American Coach American Revolution 42S can handle 7. The Thor Tuscany 45MX benefits from 4 slide-out(s), expanding the interior when parked.

Looking at self-sufficiency, the Thor Tuscany 45MX packs 84 gal of fresh water and 550W of solar. The American Coach American Revolution 42S counters with 64 gal fresh water and 200W solar.

Price is often the deciding factor. The American Coach American Revolution 42S starts at $168,000 MSRP, while the Thor Tuscany 45MX commands $175,000 — a $7,000 gap.

Families with kids will appreciate the extra sleeping capacity and living space. Off-grid campers should pay close attention to solar wattage, battery capacity, and tank sizes. Full-timers should prioritize tank capacity, storage, and overall living comfort.

No comparison can replace walking through each unit yourself. Visit a dealer and experience the layouts firsthand.